Spectracide Vs Scotts Weed Killer

There are many different weed killer brands, but the two main competitors for the top spot are Scotts Weed Killer and Spectracide. Both brands have their pros and cons, which we will discuss in this blog post. We’ll also tell you how to properly use these products to get the most out of them.

Spectracide Vs Scotts Table

Both have their advantages, but they also have their disadvantages. It is essential to do your research on the different brands before you make a purchase decision so that you can find one that works best for your lawn or garden needs.



Active Ingredients 2,4-D, Dimethylamine Salt

Active Ingredients 2, 4-D, Mecoprop-p

Kills Over 470 Weed Types

Kills Over 200 Types Of Weeds

It Won't Harm Lawns When Used As Lebel Says

Clears Out Dandelions And Clover

Visible Results In 5 Hours

Starts Working on Contact Kills

32 FL Oz Treats up to 5,000 Square Feet

One Bag Covers 5,000 Sq. Ft.

Rainfall or Watering 15 Minutes After Application Will Not Wash Away Effectiveness

Do Not Allow the Product to Be Washed off of the Weed for 1 to 2 Days After Applying.

Comes With Guaranteed Results or Your Money Back

Backed by the Scotts No Quibble Guarantee

Do Not Use on or Around Edible Feed or Food Crops

Granular Weed Control That Kills Tough Lawn Weeds, Not the Lawn

It Can Kills Listed Broadleaf And Grassy Weeds, Including Crabgrass, Dandelion, Chickweed, Clover, Yellow Nutsedge and More

It Kills Bitterweed, Black Medic, Dollarweed, Pigweed, Poison Ivy, Poison Oak, Thistle, Virginia Creeper, and Other Listed Weeds.

Why Compare?

Weed killers are vital because they kill off weeds. Some people like to spray weed killer on their lawn, for instance, while others will use it as best suited for the different plants in their garden. You can also buy a pre-mixed weed killer specially designed to eliminate certain types of plants, such as poison ivy.

Spectracide Weed Killer is well known for its fast-acting ability. It produces visible results in 5 hours. It is also non-selective, which means it will kill any plant it comes into contact with. This weed killer should not be used near desirable plants, as they will also be killed.

Scotts Weed Killer is a popular choice for people who have a lawn because it kills weeds but does not harm the grass. Scotts Weed Control for Lawns starts working on contact with the weed and kills it down to the root! However, it can be a little more expensive than Spectracide.

The main difference between Scotts and Spectracide is that Scotts Weed Killer is more selective in what it kills. It starts working on contact, While Spectracide Weed Killer kills down to the root and delivers visible results quickly, within 5 hours.

What Type Of Weed does It kill?

Spectracide Weed Stop for Lawns kills Yellow nutsedge, alder, box elder, bur oak, catnip, chicory, chickweed, dayflower, dogfennel, false flax, gray chickweed, groundsel, hairy vetch, leafy spurge, pin oak, red sorrel, sage, sagebrush, wild carrot, wild cherry.

On the other hand, Scotts Lawn Pro Weed kills Dandelions, Aster, Bittercress, Bull Thistle, Carpetweed, Chickweed, Dollarweed, Ground Ivy, Henbit, Pigweed, Purslane, Ragweed, White Clover, and over 50 Broad-leaf Weeds.

Active Ingredients

Both products are made from different active ingredients. Spectracide Weed Killer’s active ingredient is 2,4-D, dimethylamine salt, Quinclorac, while Scotts Weed Control for Lawns’ main ingredient is 2, 4-D, Dicamba, and Mecoprop-p.

2,4-D is a selective herbicide that kills broadleaf weeds in lawns, pastures, rangeland, and cereal crops. It works by inhibiting the growth of plants and is absorbed through the leaves.

Dicamba is a non-selective herbicide that kills all plants it comes into contact with. It works by causing the plant to wilt and die. Mecoprop-p is also a non-selective herbicide that works similarly to Dicamba. It kills all plants that it comes into contact with.

How Do I Apply?

Both weed killers can be applied using different methods, depending on what you are using them. For example, if you are using Spectracide Weed Killer to kill weeds in your garden, you first need to mix with the water as the label instructed. You can apply a maximum of 6.5 fl oz of product per 1,000 sq ft per application (0.6 lb 2,4-D acid equivalent per acre per application).

Scotts Weed Control for Lawns can be applied by evenly spraying it or using a spreader. It is essential to read the instructions carefully to know how to apply them properly. You can use Scotts Spreader to apply product to a dry lawn or a slightly moist one. One bag will cover 5,000 sq. ft. It would be best if you did not do this more than twice a year.

Our Observation

Weed killers are important because they help us get rid of weeds. Different people have different opinions on the best weed killer. Some people like Spectracide because it is fast-acting and kills any plant it comes into contact with.

Others like Scotts Weed Killer because it is more selective in what it kills and does not harm the grass. Both products have different active ingredients. It is important to read the instructions carefully to know how to apply them properly.


Both Spectracide and Scott’s weed killers are essential in killing weeds. They have different active ingredients that work differently on the weed. Spectracide is a non-selective herbicide that kills any plant it comes into contact with. Scotts Weed Killer is more selective and kills certain weeds. They can be applied differently, depending on what you are using them for.

Related Article

Scroll to Top