Diatomaceous Earth vs Boric Acid
Hey there! Are you struggling with a pesky roach problem and not sure how to get rid of them? Well, you’re not alone! Many people wonder which is the better solution, diatomaceous earth or boric acid. Both of these methods are highly effective, but they have some significant differences.
Top Difference
- Diatomaceous Earth is made from the fossilized remains of diatoms, a type of algae, while Boric Acid is a white powder derived from the element boron.
- Diatomaceous Earth uses its sharp edges to dehydrate and damage the exoskeleton of insects. At the same time, Boric Acid is a slow-acting poison that interferes with the metabolism and nervous system of pests.
- Diatomaceous Earth can be used in larger areas, such as attics and basements, while Boric Acid is best used in small, enclosed spaces, such as cabinets and drawers.
- Diatomaceous Earth works faster than Boric Acid, achieving a 100% mortality rate after one week, while Boric Acid can take several days to several weeks to be fully effective.
Boric Acid vs Diatomaceous Earth
Both have pros and cons, but in this table post, we will break them down for you and help you decide which is the best option for your needs. Stay tuned!
Boric Acid | Diatomaceous Earth |
 |  |
Active Ingredient Boric acid 98% | Active Ingredient Silicon Dioxide |
Not Natural But Not Harmful To Pet | 100% Natural & Pet Safe |
100% Mortality in 14 Days | 100% Mortality in 7 Days |
100% Pet to Use Around Pet and Humans | Safe on Plants and Gardens |
Only Requires Come Into Contact to Working | Only Requires Come Into Contact to Working |
Kills cockroach by Damaging Stomach and Nervous System | Kills cockroach by Damaging Exoskeleton & Dehydration |
Can Be Use Use Both Inside and Outside | Can Be Use Use Both Inside and Outside |
It Kills Kill Cockroaches, Ants, Fleas, Termites, Silverfish, Beetles, Fleas, Carpet Beetles, Wood Borers, and Other Parasites. | It Kills Cockroaches, Ants, Earwigs, Millipedes, Centipedes, Crickets, Silverfish, Fleas, Carpet Beetles, Bedbugs, Grasshoppers, Slugs and Other Crawling Insects |
Active Ingredient
Boric acid, the active ingredient in Sodium tetraborate, is a white powder derived from the element boron. This substance has been used for many years to kill cockroaches effectively and is naturally mined from mineral deposits. The process of extracting Borax from the mineral deposit is what creates the material used in the insecticide.
Diatomaceous Earth, on the other hand, is a substance made from the fossilized remains of diatoms, a type of algae. Its active ingredient, Silicon dioxide, is known for its sharp edges that puncture and dehydrate insects, leading to their ultimate demise.
This highly effective method is non-toxic for humans and pets, making it a popular choice for those looking for a natural and safe solution to their roach problem. In the ongoing battle against roaches, both Boric acid and Diatomaceous Earth have proven to be highly effective, natural, and non-toxic options.
Target Pest
As we have said, boric acid is an effective insecticide that can kill many types of insects, including Cockroaches, Ants, Fleas, Termites, Silverfish, Beetles, Fleas, Carpet Beetles, Wood Borers, and Other Parasites. This substance works by upsetting the stomach and nervous system of the insect, which leads to death.
Diatomaceous earth is also effective in getting rid of cockroaches, including Ants, Earwigs, Millipedes, Centipedes, Crickets, Silverfish, Fleas, Carpet Beetles, Bedbugs, Grasshoppers, Slugs, and Other Crawling Insects. It works by dehydrating the insect. This causes them to die of dehydration.
Both boric acid and diatomaceous earth effectively get rid of roaches, but they have different modes of action. Knowing which substance is most effective against the specific type of cockroach you are trying to get rid of is essential.
Where To Use?
Both Boric acid and Diatomaceous Earth can be used both inside and outside the house. However, the most effective use of Boric acid is in small, enclosed spaces, such as cabinets, drawers, and under appliances.
On the other hand, Diatomaceous Earth can be used in larger areas, such as the attic, basement, or outside the house. It’s important to note that for both substances, it’s essential to follow the label’s instructions for complete and safe use, including where to apply and where not to apply.
How Does It Work?
Diatomaceous Earth works against cockroaches by using its unique chemical makeup to dehydrate and damage their exoskeletons. The substance is made up of tiny, sharp particles that penetrate the exoskeleton of insects, causing them to dry out and ultimately die.
Once diatomaceous earth is applied, the particles stick to the cockroaches’ bodies and legs, which carries the substance back to their hiding spots. As a result, diatomaceous earth can effectively target entire cockroach populations, making it a popular and efficient solution for getting rid of roaches. Additionally, Diatomaceous Earth is a natural and non-toxic substance for humans and pets, making it a safe alternative to harsh chemical insecticides.
Boric acid works against cockroaches by poisoning their stomachs and nervous systems. When cockroaches ingest boric acid, it interferes with their metabolism and prevents them from processing food correctly. As a result, the roaches will become dehydrated and ultimately die.
Additionally, the acid can also adhere to the roaches’ bodies and legs, which can lead to further poisoning once they groom themselves or other cockroaches. Boric acid is a slow-acting insecticide that allows roaches to carry the poison back to their hiding spots and other members of their colony, effectively targeting the entire population. However, it’s essential to use boric acid carefully and in accordance with the label’s instructions to avoid any potential hazards to humans or pets.
Our Observation
One key observation of the difference between Diatomaceous Earth and Boric Acid for cockroach control is their mode of action. Diatomaceous Earth uses its sharp edges to dehydrate and damage the exoskeleton of insects, leading to their demise. On the other hand, boric acid is a slow-acting poison that interferes with the cockroach’s metabolism and nervous system, ultimately leading to dehydration and death.
This difference in the mode of action can affect the speed and efficiency of each substance in getting rid of cockroaches. Another significant difference between the two is their application. Diatomaceous Earth can be used in larger areas, making it a popular choice for attics, basements, and outdoor spaces. It’s also non-toxic and safe for humans and pets, making it an ideal solution for those who want to avoid harsh chemicals.
On the other hand, Boric Acid is best used in small, enclosed spaces, such as cabinets and drawers, making it a popular choice for targeted cockroach control. However, boric acid can be toxic if used incorrectly and should be handled carefully.
Overall, both Diatomaceous Earth and Boric Acid are highly effective and natural solutions for getting rid of cockroaches, but the choice of which to use depends on factors such as the severity of the infestation, the location of the infestation, and personal preference.
Related Article
