Talstar PL vs Xtra Insecticide

In this comparative study, we delve into the specifics of two leading insecticides, Talstar PL and Talstar XTRA, highlighting their active ingredients, effectiveness, technology, and safety to help you make an informed pest control choice.

Talstar PL vs Xtra Table

What is the difference between Talstar XTRA and Talstar PL? This article will discuss their similarities, differences, and benefits.

Talstar XTRA

Talstar PL

Active Ingredient Bifenthrin & Zeta Cypermethrin

Talstar PL contains 0.2% Bifenthrin as its active ingredient

Proven to eliminate dangerous fire ant colonies in just 15 minutes.

Proven to eliminate dangerous fire ant invaders within 24 hours.

Once the granules are watered in, it is safe for pets.

Once the granules are watered in, it is safe for pets.

It provides up to four months of reliable control of most ants (including fire ants) and other pests.

It provides long-term protection against pests for two to four months.

One 25-lb Bag Can You Can Treat Approximately 11,000 Square Feet

One 25 lb. bag of Talstar PL treats between 5,000 to 10,000 square feet

Odor Free & Almost Completely Dustless

Low Odor, No Staining & No Plant Burn

Get Up To Four Months Of Reliable Long-lasting Residual Protection

It Is Labeled For Food-handling Areas Such As Kitchens Or Food Processing Plants.

Proven To Eliminate Dangerous Fire Ant Colonies In Four Hours Or Less

Compatible With Herbicides, Fungicides, Insecticides And Liquid Fertilizers.

It kills Most Ants (except pharaoh ants), Fire Ants, Chinch Bugs, Fleas, Ticks, Mole Crickets, Crane Flies And Many Other Lawn Pests.

Designed to control a broad spectrum of pests including ants, fleas, ticks, crickets, centipedes, and more.

Active Ingredient
Talstar PL utilizes Bifenthrin, a highly potent insecticide, as its main active ingredient at a concentration of 0.2%. Bifenthrin is a type of synthetic pyrethroid that is especially effective in exterminating a broad range of insects by attacking their nervous systems. 

It disrupts the normal functioning of their nerves, leading to paralysis and, ultimately, their demise. Meanwhile, Talstar XTRA includes Bifenthrin (0.2%) and Zeta-Cypermethrin (0.05%) as active ingredients.

The addition of Zeta-Cypermethrin is particularly notable for its ability to knock down pests quickly, leading to their accelerated extermination.

Effective Pest Control
Talstar XTRA and Talstar PL are known for their extensive pest control abilities. Talstar XTRA is designed to control over 75 different species of lawn pests, demonstrating its broad-spectrum versatility.

Similarly, Talstar PL exhibits a broad-spectrum approach towards pest control, managing many pests such as ants, fleas, ticks, crickets, centipedes, and more, thereby contributing to a healthier lawn and garden.

These products also provide long-lasting pest control. Talstar XTRA, after a single application, can offer reliable control of most ants (including fire ants) and other pests for up to four months.

Talstar PL offers long-term protection against pests, with effectiveness lasting between two to four months. This long-lasting nature makes these products economical and convenient for homeowners, minimizing the need for frequent reapplication.

Both products act fast against pests. Talstar XTRA can eliminate hazardous fire ant colonies in a mere 15 minutes.  Talstar PL also acts swiftly, successfully eliminating harmful fire ant invaders within 24 hours. This fast action protects your lawn and garden from extensive damage these pests can cause.

Innovative Technology
Talstar PL and Talstar XTRA use advanced technologies to enhance their effectiveness. Talstar PL employs a sand-core granular structure that enhances its ability to penetrate deep into the mulch and grass, thus ensuring a more extensive reach of the insecticide.

In contrast, Talstar XTRA utilizes Verge granule technology, which disintegrates quickly when watered, dissolving into micro-particles that penetrate the soil to reach the target pests.

Versatile Use
Talstar PL and Talstar XTRA are approved for use in various outdoor settings, making them versatile pest control solutions. These include residential lawns, institutional grounds like schools and hospitals, public parks, recreational and athletic fields, and various buildings, including public, commercial, and industrial establishments.

Coverage Area
The coverage area for Talstar PL and Talstar XTRA depends on the concentration used. Generally, a 25 lb. bag of either product can treat an area between 5,000 to 10,000 square feet, providing comprehensive protection for most residential and commercial landscapes.

Pet Safe
Both Talstar PL and Talstar XTRA are formulated to be safe for pets once the granules are watered in and settled. This ensures you can maintain a pest-free environment while keeping your pets safe.

Safety Concern
While Talstar PL and Talstar XTRA are designed to be safe for mammals, they are highly toxic to fish and other aquatic organisms. They should never be allowed to enter drains or water courses, as they can cause significant harm to aquatic ecosystems. Responsible usage and disposal of these products are critical to prevent environmental damage.

Our Observation
Talstar PL and Talstar XTRA demonstrate effective pest control capabilities, but for fast, comprehensive, and extended protection, Talstar XTRA seems to edge out. Its dual active ingredients, Bifenthrin and Zeta-Cypermethrin, enable rapid pest knockdown.

Its innovative Verge granule technology ensures quick dissolution and extensive coverage, while its four-month protection period provides long-lasting peace of mind.

However, both are toxic to aquatic life, mandating careful use to prevent environmental harm. Overall, Talstar XTRA stands as the superior choice for quick action and enduring control.

Related Article

Scroll to Top